| 2024 Scott Hrabcak* | 1989 William McMenamy* | 1954 Edgar Johnson | 1918 Myron Smith |
| 2023 Patti Brown-Wright | 1988 Margie Coyle Holzer | 1953 Robert Denmead* | 1917 Charles Johnson |
| 2022 Sue Van Woerkom | 1987 Richard Fagan | 1952 Charles Bechtol | 1916 T. Harry Marshall |
| 2021 Michael Jones | 1986 George Simpson* | 1951 Emerson Wollam | 1915 William Zinn |
| 2020 Andy Mills* | 1985 Ed Carr* | 1950 Wallace Nelson | 1914 William Heston |
| 2019 John Myers | 1984 Don Kelley* | 1949 George Tifft | 1913 Ross Cheek |
| 2018 Sara Walsh | 1983 Max Holzer | 1948 Wilburn Kerr | 1912 W. G. Conway |
| 2017 Mic Gordon | 1982 Joe MacKinnon | 1947 Mark Hendrickson | 1911 Elmore Putman |
| 2016 John Royer* | 1981 Gary Seckel* | 1946 Francis Paddock | 1911 Elmore Putman |
| 2015 Kathy Shiflet | 1980 Michael Griffith* | 1945 Henry Wollam | 1910 Demmie Cooke |
| 2014 Milt Lustnauer | 1979 Myrna Kobre | 1944 Malcolm Prine | 1908-09 Frank Hammond |
| 2013 Chris Pedon | 1978 Richard Ward | 1943 Hayden Edwards | |
| 2012 Jim Coridan* | 1977 Richard Royer* | 1942 Roy Brenholts | |
| 2011 Rick Benjamin | 1976 Robert Weiler* | 1941 Preston Cooke | |
| 2010 Sue Lusk-Gleich | 1975 Larry Horn | 1940 W. H. McAllister | |
| 2009 Gary Parsons | 1974 Thomas Caito | 1939 John Galbreath* | |
| 2008 Gregory Hrabcak* | 1973 Twink Starr | 1938 Paul Kohr* | |
| 2007 Brad Bennett | 1972 Jim Owen | 1937 Manch Wallace | |
| 2006 Chris Reese | 1971 Brad Salt | 1936 Gilbert Carmack | |
| 2005 Doug McCloud* | 1970 John Hill | 1935 Ivan Gore | |
| 2004 Skip Weiler* | 1969 Harley Rouda | 1934 C.L. Converse | |
| 2003 Robert U. Miller | 1968 Bill McCorkle | 1933 Frank Shawaker | |
| 2002 Lynda Long | 1967 Ted Seckel* | 1932 Corwin Fergus | |
| 2001 Barbara Lach | 1966 John Ranft | 1931 Harley Stoneburner | |
| 2000 Bruce Massa* | 1965 Orin Morris | 1930 Herman Johnson | |
| 1999 Mary Raysa | 1964 Marvin Yerke | 1929 Harry Samuels | |
| 1998 Mike Huntley | 1963 Paul Falco* | 1928 Leigh Koebel | |
| 1997 Samuel S. Calhoon | 1962 John Pace | 1927 Edmund Arras | |
| 1996 Patrick J. O'Neil | 1961 Oscar Thomas* | 1926 D. Wendell Beggs* | |
| 1995 Stephen Wittmann* | 1960 Thomas Kohr* | 1925 Frank Marion | |
| 1994 Charlotte Van Steyn | 1959 Cecil Neff | 1924 Perl Miller | |
| 1993 George Smith | 1958 Herbert Wolfe | 1923 John Baker | |
| 1992 Patrick Grabill | 1957 Larry Wade | 1922 J. Elwood Bulen | |
| 1991 John Myers | 1956 Lee Wears* | 1921 John McCrehen | |
| 1990 Nancy Sharp | 1955 Robert Weiler* | 1919 King Thompson |
*Commercial